Fundamentals of Midwifery: A Textbook for Students

Edited by Louise Lewis

Cases

Chapter 14 Complementary and alternative medicines applied to maternity care

Case 1: Raspberry leaf tea

A woman presents at clinic at 34 weeks gestation with what appears to be a healthy non-problematic pregnancy. She asks you if and when she should start using raspberry leaf tea.

    Questions

  • a) How would you respond to this question?

    Correct answer:
    Raspberry leaf tea is associated with aiding the process of labour and delivery; however, as yet, scientific research has found no evidence to support this claim. This does not mean that it is not effective, but for now, most of the evidence for the effective use of raspberry leaf tea is anecdotal. It has yet to be proven to be 100% safe and reliable and effective by randomised controlled trials. There is considerable discussion around the possible benefits of raspberry leaf tea taken late in pregnancy, however as a midwife you should make yourself aware of the best available evidence to date, and a review of raspberry leaf tea undertaken by Holst et al. in 2009 (on safety and efficacy of raspberry leaf tea) concluded that although raspberry leaf has been in traditional use for a very long time, the evidence regarding safety, efficacy and active constituents is weak. More research is necessary before raspberry leaf should be recommended by healthcare personnel.
    Holst, L., Haavnik, S., Nordeng, H. (2009) Raspberry leaf - Should it be recommended to pregnant women? Complementary Therapies in Clinical Practice; 15(4), pp 204-208.

Case 2: Use of lavender oil

A woman who is currently using lavender oil as a treatment for perineal trauma is experiencing some itching and discomfort in the peri-anal region.

    Questions

  • a) What would you do and what would you advise the woman to do?

    Correct answer:
    Ask relevant questions about the itching and discomfort to facilitate in building a clinical picture. The itching may be the sign of an infection, or it may be due to the use of the lavender oil itself. It is important to try and distinguish between the two and the midwife should use other clinical observations to do so. It is important to gain an understanding of the patterns of use of lavender oil, dilution rates etc. Refer to the woman's notes and discuss use of lavender oil with the woman to gain further information. Women using lavender oil directly upon the perineum should be advised that current evidence suggests its use in highly diluted forms when directly applied to the skin. Skin cell viability of 80-100% was identified at an oil concentration of 0.125%, thereafter an increase in concentration affected cell viability (Prashar et al. 2004). In recommended doses, it is generally considered well-tolerated with minimal adverse effects. Lis Balchin (2006) states that due to the risk of contact with delicate mucosal membranes, the use of oils in sensitive areas should be avoided; however it is not clear if this advice applies to lavender oil in an appropriately diluted solution or neat application. Advise against the use of lavender until the itching and discomfort has stopped, and suggest consulting the GP if symptoms continue after stopping lavender oil treatment. Nursing and Midwifery Council (NMC) registrants are reminded that the use of complementary and alternative therapies should be safe and in the best interests of women and midwives should respect women's rights to self-administer.
    Lis Balchin, M. (2006) Aromatherapy Science. London: Pharmaceutical Press.
    Prashar, A., Locke, I.C., Evans, C.S. (2004) Cytotoxicity of lavender oil and its major components to human skin cells. Cell Proliferation 37, pp221-229.
    Jones, C. (2011) The efficacy of lavender oil on perineal trauma: a review of the evidence. Complementary Therapies in Clinical Practice 17(4), pp.215-220.

Case 3: Acupuncture

A woman who is 18 weeks pregnant and experiencing pelvic girdle pain asks you if she would benefit from having a course of acupuncture.

    Questions

  • a) What would you do and how would go about responding to this question?

    Correct answer:
    Possible mental health concerns include anxiety, postnatal depression, other long standing mental health problems not previously disclosed.

  • b) What would be the health professional's actions?

    Correct answer:
    The midwife should refer to the best available evidence. Research by Elden et al. (2005) has shown that acupuncture and stabilising exercises constitute efficient complements to standard treatment for the management of pelvic girdle pain during pregnancy. Acupuncture was found to be superior to stabilising exercises in this study of pregnant women from gestations of 12-31 weeks. The range of training and educational courses in complementary and alternative health is vast, and midwives shouldn't be expected to have unlimited knowledge about such matters; therefore when advising women on the use of CAM through a practitioner, midwives should refer women to an appropriate resource in relation to the type of therapy under discussion. Women should be encouraged to make the use of professional bodies and voluntary registers relevant to the discipline for which they are enquiring, such as the Complementary and Natural Healthcare Council (CNHC), or the British Acupuncture Council to help them find a practitioner.
    Elden, H., Ladfors, L., Olsen, M.F., Ostgaard, H.C., Hagberg. H. (2005) Effects of acupuncture and stabilising exercises as adjunct to standard treatment in pregnant women with pelvic girdle pain: randomised single blind controlled trial. British Medical Journal doi:10.1136/bmj.38397.507014.E0.

Print Answer | « Previous Case | Next Case »